With Shopify’s introduction of New Customer Accounts, business owners must evaluate whether to adopt this new system or stick with the Classic Customer Accounts. Both have unique advantages, but making the right choice depends on your business needs, customer experience goals, and technical capabilities.

Understanding Classic Customer Accounts

Classic Customer Accounts require users to create an account with a username and password. Once logged in, customers can:

• View past orders
• Save shipping and billing addresses
• Manage personal details

Advantages of Classic Customer Accounts

• Familiar login system: Customers accustomed to traditional accounts may prefer using a password.
• Integration with existing systems: Many Shopify merchants have built workflows around Classic Accounts, including CRM and loyalty programs.
• Stronger control over customer data: Merchants have more direct access to stored customer information for marketing and service purposes.

Limitations of Classic Customer Accounts

With studies showing that 24% of customers abandon their carts due to forced account creation, it’s important to highlight the limitations caused by traditional logins.

• Login friction: Forgotten passwords can lead to lost sales and abandoned carts.
• Security risks: Password-based logins are more vulnerable to data breaches and credential stuffing attacks.
• Limited scalability: As Shopify evolves, maintaining Classic Customer Accounts could become more challenging for large-scale businesses.

The Evolution: Shopify New Customer Accounts

New Customer Accounts are designed to streamline the user experience by eliminating the need for passwords. Instead, customers log in using a one-time passcode sent via email.

Key Features of New Customer Accounts

• Seamless login process: No passwords, reducing friction and increasing conversion rates.
• Auto-login from checkout emails: Customers can access their accounts directly from order confirmation emails.
• Cross-device accessibility: A more unified experience across mobile and desktop without requiring reauthentication.
• Enhanced security: Shopify handles authentication, reducing the risk of data breaches.

How New Customer Accounts Benefit Enterprise Merchants

1. Higher Conversion Rates: By removing password barriers, customers can complete purchases with minimal disruption.
2. Stronger Data Protection: Passcode-based logins enhance security without the need for merchants to store passwords.
3. Better Customer Experience: Faster logins lead to higher engagement and repeat purchases.
4. Simplified Account Management: Less friction in creating and accessing accounts means more customers use them, improving retention.

Classic vs. New Customer Accounts: A Detailed Comparison

Choosing the Right Account Type for Your Business

When to Stick with Classic Customer Accounts

• Your business has extensive integrations dependent on password-based logins.
• You manage a loyalty program or subscription service that relies on Classic Account structures.
• Your customers prefer a traditional account system with saved credentials.

When to Switch to New Customer Accounts

• You want to reduce cart abandonment rates caused by login issues.
• Your business values security and compliance without the burden of password management.
• You’re leveraging Shopify’s latest B2B and checkout extensibility features, which are optimized for New Customer Accounts.

Transitioning to New Customer Accounts: Best Practices

For enterprise businesses considering migration, here are key steps to ensure a smooth transition:

1. Audit Your Existing Customer Data: Identify dependencies on Classic Accounts, including third-party integrations.
2. Communicate Changes to Customers: Inform users about the new login process and its benefits through email campaigns and support channels.
3. Test the Experience: Run A/B tests to measure the impact on login rates and checkout completion.
4. Monitor Performance: Use Shopify analytics to track adoption rates and optimize the user experience.

Ready to Make the Switch: Classic vs. New Customer Accounts on Shopify

The transition from Classic to New Customer Accounts reflects Shopify’s dedication to improving user experience and security. While Classic Accounts remain functional, New Customer Accounts are better suited to meet the evolving demands of modern e-commerce. Enterprise merchants should carefully evaluate their business needs, customer behavior, and technical infrastructure before making the switch.

If you’re looking to transition to New Customer Accounts or optimize your Shopify store, our expert team at Makro is here to help. Specializing in Shopify development and design, we provide strategic solutions tailored to your goals. Contact us today to future-proof your e-commerce experience!

‍